The individual investor of today is not short of brokerages to choose from. But in the face of a monster platform like Interactive Brokers (IBKR), being spoilt for choice is both a blessing and a curse.
IBKR is commonly regarded as one of the most comprehensive online brokerage platforms, boasting a wealth of assets, tools, and resources. And we’d admit it, it’s pretty tough to cut through the clutter.
In this review, we demystify IBKR’s capabilities and how it fares against other popular brokerages—particularly Saxo Markets and Tiger Brokers.
Contents:
What is Interactive Brokers?
What are the Interactive Brokers Singapore fees, products, and platforms?
What are the Interactive Brokers Singapore commission fees?
What happened to the Interactive Brokers inactivity fee?
Interactive Brokers vs Saxo—which is better?
Interactive Brokers vs Tiger Brokers—which is better?
A final overview—IBKR vs Saxo vs Tiger Brokers
How do I start trading on Interactive Brokers?
Which is better—IBKR Lite or IBKR Pro?
What is Interactive Brokers?
Interactive Brokers is an American brokerage firm that also operates in Singapore. It is currently one of the US’s biggest trading platforms and also has a strong presence in Asia.
The company is listed on NASDAQ, so if you want to be really meta, you can even trade IBKR shares on your Interactive Brokers platform.
Interactive Brokers’ platform lets you invest in stocks, options, futures, currencies, bonds and funds in over 150 markets worldwide, including our good old Singapore Exchange.
More importantly, it’s also one of the cheapest trading accounts available at the moment.
What are the Interactive Brokers Singapore fees, products, and platforms?
Here’s an overview of Interactive Brokers’ fees, trading products, platforms, and more.
Trading products
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, metals, cryptocurrencies
Minimum commission fee (SG stocks)
0.08% (2.50 SGD minimum)
Minimum commission fee (US stocks)
0.005 USD per share (1 USD minimum)
Minimum funding amount
None
Stock Holding Type
Custodian
Trading platforms
Trader Workstation, Client Portal, IBKR Mobile and IBKR APIs
Payment method
Bank transfer and cheque
Inactivity fee
None
What are the Interactive Brokers Singapore commission fees?
For Singapore shares, Interactive Brokers charges a commission fee of 0.08%, with a minimum commission of 2.50 SGD.
IBKR’s $2.50 minimum commission is one of the lowest in the market, with bank brokers like DBS Vickers or OCBC Securities charging as much as S$25 per trade.
For small trades on SGX, Interactive Brokers is certainly cheaper than Saxo Markets, which charges a $5 minimum commission for their $1/month Bronze plan. However, you can go even cheaper with newcomers like Tiger Brokers and Moomoo. Compare the cheapest brokerages for Singapore stocks here.
For US stocks, Interactive Brokers is charging 0.005 USD per share, subject to a minimum of 1 USD. This is one of the lowest minimum commissions on the market, only behind brokers like Moomoo, Webull and TD Ameritrade.
With IBKR’s low minimum commissions, you can go right ahead and make itty bitty trades without worrying about losing money to hefty commission fees.
What happened to the Interactive Brokers inactivity fee?
In the past, Interactive Brokers was known for having one huge drawback: inactivity fees unless you fulfilled certain criteria.
Basically, you had to generate at least 10 to 20 USD worth of commissions in a calendar month in order to avoid inactivity fees every month.
But as of 9 July 2021, IBKR has finally got rid of the inactivity fee. Now we need not worry about being forced to trade in order to avoid the fee. Hurray!
Interactive Brokers vs Saxo Markets—which is better?
Saxo Markets is another established online brokerage brand that is popular in Singapore, and is known for its affordable trading fees.
Let’s compare Interactive Brokers and Saxo.
Interactive Brokers
Saxo
Trading products
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, metals, cryptocurrencies
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, commodities, CFDs, cryptocurrencies
Minimum commission fee (SG stocks)
0.08% (2.50 SGD minimum)
0.03%-0.08%(1-5 SGD minimum)
Minimum commission fee (US stocks)
0.005 USD per share (1 USD minimum)
0.02%-0.06%(1-4 USD minimum)
Minimum funding amount
None
S$3,000 (Bronze account plan) / S$0 (other plans)
Stock Holding Type
Custodian
Custodian
Trading platforms
Trader Workstation, Client Portal, IBKR Mobile and IBKR APIs
SaxoInvestor, SaxoTraderGO, SaxoTraderPRO
Payment method
Bank transfer and cheque
FAST, PayNow, MEPS, internet bank transfer or credit/debit card
Inactivity fee
None
None
Custody fee
None
0.12% per annum on stocks, ETFs/ETCs or bonds that are outside SGX
In terms of commission fees, Interactive Brokers is generally cheaper to use than Saxo Markets, especially if you only get Saxo’s most basic account plan.
For SG stocks, Saxo’s minimum commission fees are higher than IBKR’s unless you’re on Saxo’s Silver plan (the second-lowest) or higher. For US stocks, IBKR charges lower minimum commissions than Saxo even if you pay for Saxo’s top-tier Diamond plan. Clearly, IBKR is the cheaper choice for small and frequent trades.
What about larger, less frequent trades? Unfortunately, Saxo charges an annual custody fee of 0.12% on your holdings outside the SGX. So if you’re more of a buy-and-hold investor, this fee will add up over time.
Interactive Brokers vs Tiger Brokers—which is better?
If you’re a cost-conscious investor, you’d have heard of Tiger Brokers. Though not as established as IBKR, Tiger Brokers is a new brokerage that has IBKR as one of their investors.
Tiger Brokers is known for dangling some very attractive welcome offers, such as free shares, up to 60 commission-free trades, and rewards in the form of Tiger coins.
Let’s compare the fees and charges for Interactive Brokers and Tiger Brokers.
Interactive Brokers
Tiger Brokers
Trading products
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, metals, cryptocurrencies
Stocks, ETFs, REITs, indices, metals, treasury, energy futures
Minimum commission fee (SG stocks)
0.08% (2.50 SGD minimum)
0.03% (0.99 SGD minimum)
Platform fee (SG stocks)
None
0.03% (1 SGD minimum)
Minimum commission fee (US stocks)
0.005 USD per share (1 USD minimum)
0.005 USD per share (0.99 USD minimum)
Minimum funding amount
None
None
Stock Holding Type
Custodian
CDP
Trading platforms
Trader Workstation, Client Portal, IBKR Mobile and IBKR APIs
Tiger Brokers desktop app and mobile app
Payment method
Bank transfer and cheque
FAST, PayNow, Internet Bank Transfer or Credit/ Debit Card, MEPS, Wise
Inactivity fee
None
None
Custody fee
None
None
Tiger Brokers charges a lower commission fee than IBKR. Like IBKR, they also don’t impose any minimum funding amount, inactivity fee or custody fee.
That said, bear in mind that Tiger Brokers is still a more new entrant. Its track record isn’t as good as IBKR’s, which is one of the most established brokerages out there. Just last year, one Singaporean lost about S$15,000 on the Tiger Brokers platform following an increase in their transaction fees with no fee cap. Tiger Brokers implemented a fee cap after the incident.
Both IBKR and Tiger Brokers are more suited to beginner investors than Saxo. While IBKR and Tiger Brokers have practically no minimum funding requirements, Saxo requires an initial deposit of $3,000.
A final overview—IBKR vs Saxo vs Tiger Brokers
Interactive Brokers
Saxo
Tiger Brokers
Trading products
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, metals, cryptocurrencies
Stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, FX, mutual funds, commodities, CFDs, cryptocurrencies
Stocks, ETFs, REITs, indices, metals, treasury, energy futures
Minimum commission fee (SG stocks)
0.08% (2.50 SGD minimum)
0.03%-0.08%(1-5 SGD minimum)
0.03% (0.99 SGD minimum)
Platform fee (SG stocks)
None
None
0.03% (1 SGD minimum)
Minimum commission fee (US stocks)
0.005 USD per share (1 USD minimum)
0.02%-0.06%(1-4 USD minimum)
0.005 USD per share (0.99 USD minimum)
Minimum funding amount
None
S$3,000 (Bronze account plan) / S$0 (other plans)
None
Stock Holding Type
Custodian
Custodian
CDP
Trading platforms
Trader Workstation, Client Portal, IBKR Mobile and IBKR APIs
SaxoInvestor, SaxoTraderGO, SaxoTraderPRO
Tiger Brokers desktop app and mobile app
Payment method
Bank transfer, cheque
FAST, PayNow, MEPS, internet bank transfer or credit/debit card
FAST, PayNow, Internet Bank Transfer or Credit/ Debit Card, MEPS, Wise
Inactivity fee
None
None
None
Custody fee
None
0.12% per annum on stocks, ETFs/ETCs or bonds that are outside SGX
None
How do I start trading on Interactive Brokers?
You can apply for an Interactive Brokers account through MoneySmart.
You will need to divulge information about your income, which can be done quite easily if you log into MyInfo using your SingPass.
Once your account has been approved, you can simply transfer money via internet banking and start trading right away.
Which is better—IBKR Lite or IBKR Pro?
If you’re a Singapore resident, you don’t have a choice—you’ll be automatically assigned an IBKR Pro account.
The other option, IBKR Lite, is only for US-based investors. This is a simplified version of their trading platform which offers commission-free, unlimited trading of US stocks and ETFs.
Don’t be fooled by the name. You don’t have to be a pro to use a Macbook Pro, and the same goes for the IBKR Pro platform. It’s just a normal trading platform that’s more “complete” than the dumbed-down IBKR Lite.
Found this article useful? Share it with anyone who’s considering an IBKR account.
Cover image: Nicholas Cappello on Unsplash
The post Interactive Brokers Singapore Review (2023): How does it fare against Saxo Markets and Tiger Brokers? appeared first on the MoneySmart blog.
MoneySmart.sg helps you maximize your money. Like us on Facebook to keep up to date with our latest news and articles.
Compare and shop for the best deals on Loans, Insurance and Credit Cards on our site now!
The post Interactive Brokers Singapore Review (2023): How does it fare against Saxo Markets and Tiger Brokers? appeared first on MoneySmart.sg.
Original article: Interactive Brokers Singapore Review (2023): How does it fare against Saxo Markets and Tiger Brokers?.
© 2009-2018 Catapult Ventures Pte Ltd. All rights reserved.